Immigration, Assimilation, Ethnicity and All That Jazz

Canada’s C-50: Limitation on Immigration

Posted by chinesecanuck on April 19, 2008

Many people want to come to Canada.  So many, in fact, that Canada is currently looking at changing its immigration policies so that some people could be fast-tracked in.  This includes people who are in highly trained jobs such as medicine or engineering.  Prospective immigrants are already complaining that they need to wait years to get in, especially those who are highly educated or skilled.  So why should these people have to wait?

However, what upsets people is that the bill apparently indicates that the government can pick and choose which countries prospective immigrants come from (some websites even say that the minister can do it.  NOT TRUE.  Why would she?  She doesn’t have the time!).  Some people are going as far as saying that it’s a big step backwards, back to the early twentieth century or before.  But what they don’t realize is that the government is already “picking and choosing”.  There are already very strict requirements to get in, believe it or not, and technically, the people from certain countries ARE more likely to be rejected because they don’t meet the standards.

What would I do?  Considering that many immigrants to Canada seem to prefer their old ways of doing things (but at the same time, enjoy the freedoms that we give them, things that weren’t possible in the old country), I’d require prospective immigrants to watch videos about life in Canada so that they wouldn’t be in for a shock when they come.  They’d should also be required to answer questions like:

  1. You child has been paired up with a member of the opposite sex (or child whose family is from an “enemy” country) for a school assignment.  How would you react?  Would you force the teacher to find the child another partner? (If the parents say yes, then points are deducted)
  2. At a work gathering, one of your co-workers introduces you to his (her) spouse.  His (her) spouse is a man (woman).  How would you feel about that? (I know that plenty of people in Canada are homophobic, but we don’t want to increase the numbers, do we?) 
  3. A couple lives next door to you.  They seem lovely and very friendly.  At a dinner party, you find out that they aren’t legally married.  In fact, they have no intention of getting married.  Will you still be friends with them? (again, I know that plenty of people are anti-shacking up before marriage, but like homophobics, we don’t need more of them in this country.)
  4. Your (now grown) child doesn’t want to marry the person that was arranged for him/her.  Instead, the child wants to marry someone they’re in love with (or not at all).  To you, the show must go on.  Is there anything wrong with the picture? (brownie points for those who say yes :-))
  5. You move into a neighbourhood that is primarily made up of people who speak your language and enjoy your traditions.  Do you think it’s necessary to learn English (or French)?  If not, why not? 

I know some of these questions sound a little crazy, and may also apply to certain groups who’ve been in this country for years, but like I’ve said before, we don’t need MORE people like that here.  And I think if more people had an open mind when they arrive, there’d be less tension between different groups and also less tension between parents and their Canadian raised children.

Toronto Star article on Bill C-50

Website that opposes C-50

Citizenship and Immigration Canada website


7 Responses to “Canada’s C-50: Limitation on Immigration”

  1. Scapegoat said

    6. Your daughter wants to dress like western teenagers. Do you:
    a. Take her shopping at the Gap.
    b. Negotiate with her and find a compromise.
    c. Kill her.

    7. Do you see your child marrying:
    a. a nice person of any race.
    b. another immigrant from your own race.
    c. a mail-order groom/bride.

    8. Your son/daughter wants to major in a field other than medicine, engineering, computers, law, business or accounting. What would you do?

    9. What if your son/daughter wants to attend a non-ethnic church?

    10. Your coworker is married with a dog and no children. Would you tell her that pets are not considered family?

    11. Which of the following are polite questions to ask?
    a. How are you?
    b. What’s your favourite hockey team?
    c. What do you do?
    d. What’s your salary?
    e. How much do you weigh?
    f. How old are you?
    g. What mark did you get on that school assignment?
    h. When are you gonna get married?
    i. When are you gonna have kids?

    12. Your 16-year-old daughter wants to take driving lessons. What do you think is an appropriate age for women to start driving?
    a. 16
    b. 40
    c. Not in this lifetime.

  2. Scapegoat, re: #8:

    For some cultures, pre-law/law isn’t considered a “proper” major!

  3. Alston said

    I think that it should be stressed more to immigrants that things will be different and that they should have an open mind. That said, as a Canadian citizen, they should be able to live the way they want to and think what they want.

  4. But Alston, don’t you think that can be dangerous? I mean, if parents tell a kid that such-and-such a culture is wrong and you can’t hang out with people from such-and-such a culture, what would you do?

  5. Alston said

    That happens with established Canadians and new Canadians alike. I don’t know what I would do, or if I should do anything. Frankly, I don’t care as long as they don’t expect me to conform to their morality. I have enough problems with the prevailing one as it is.

  6. James said

    When you move in another country, you have to obey their laws, even Canada… The majority makes decisions when changing the laws.

  7. James said

    I think bill C-50 is great because if this country lets too many people in, our rights and our country will be eroded and it will be too late… I’m opposed to letting in hundreds of thousands in each year and it should be cut down to minimize growth… I also oppose major urban development that destroys many of the nice country and farm lands in the Greater Toronto Area… This country needs control before it’s too late.

    Note from Chinese Canuck: I’ve changed it ever so slightly

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: